That's a fair call about Lisa Simpson, I guess I was more focused on her dynamic within her own family as she was often portrayed as the know-it-all/misunderstood type which is something I feel would be common for female INTJs.
I would argue that the traits you claim Hermione has, that distinguish her from an INTJ (emotive, desire for companionship, duty etc) do not exclude her from fitting this personality, as I personally feel I have (most of) these traits and yet still relate 90% to the INTJ personality. However claiming her as an ISTJ could very well be accurate as she is also defined by her tendency to only believe facts, books and "cold hard evidence" as opposed which is strongly associated with ISTJ.
Guest (not verified)says...
That's a fair call about Lisa Simpson, I guess I was more focused on her dynamic within her own family as she was often portrayed as the know-it-all/misunderstood type which is something I feel would be common for female INTJs.
I would argue that the traits you claim Hermione has, that distinguish her from an INTJ (emotive, desire for companionship, duty etc) do not exclude her from fitting this personality, as I personally feel I have (most of) these traits and yet still relate 90% to the INTJ personality. However claiming her as an ISTJ could very well be accurate as she is also defined by her tendency to only believe facts, books and "cold hard evidence" as opposed which is strongly associated with ISTJ.